Mailchimp vs Office AutoPilot - Why we switched

For years, we used Mailchimp as our go-to email service provider. It’s a great entry-level tool for sending campaigns or building basic email sequences. The interface is user-friendly, and the reports are comprehensive—telling you who opened your email, clicked which links, and how often. This kind of data is vital when trying to refine your content to meet your audience's needs.

But as our business grew, Mailchimp’s limitations became obvious.

The Core Limitations of Mailchimp

1. No Integrated CRM

   Mailchimp is not a true CRM. If you want to track phone calls, emails, meetings, or sales history, you’ll need to connect another CRM like Salesforce, Capsule, or Batchbook. This adds complexity and requires managing two separate systems, which inevitably leads to the CRM being underutilised.

   
   

2. Clunky Segmentation

   You want to send targeted content to different groups—tax clients, family lawyers, commercial litigation professionals, but Mailchimp’s list and group management is far from seamless. Clients can end up on multiple lists and receive duplicate emails. Using groups to segment requires manual effort and risks errors when importing data.

   
   

3. No Smart Automation

   Mailchimp lacks rules-based automation. For example, if someone clicks a link expressing interest in SMSFs, Mailchimp won’t automatically update their profile or trigger a relevant sequence. You have to export data manually, tag it in Excel, and re-upload it. It’s a tedious, error-prone process.

   
   

4. Poor Data Filtering

   Mailchimp’s database search and segmentation features are basic. The add-on tool ‘Hairball’ improves filtering slightly, but it’s clunky and still disconnected from the main system.

When you’re relying on email to drive revenue, lost opportunities and disjointed systems can cost you thousands.

Why We Switched to Office Autopilot (Now Ontraport)

Office Autopilot changed how we manage our contacts, send emails, and automate our workflows.

Here’s why:

1. Tag-Based Segmentation

You can add unlimited tags to each contact. A client can be tagged as Client: Tax, Lead: SMSF, and Event: Webinar. Tags are automatically added based on behaviours like clicking a link or purchasing a product. This means we can send highly tailored campaigns without any manual input.

2. Automation Rules That Actually Work

Office Autopilot allows you to build rules and sequences. For example, if someone buys a product, it can:

• Remove their “Prospect” tag

• Add a “Customer” and product-specific tag

• Trigger a welcome sequence

• Notify our team for onboarding

No spreadsheets. No importing. No missed steps.

3. True CRM Functionality

Unlike Mailchimp, Office Autopilot acts as a full CRM. You can log phone calls, emails, and meeting notes directly against the contact. Better still, you can automate workflows based on those events.

4. Offline Tasks & Fulfilment

Create task sequences for your team like:

• Send a printed welcome pack

• Schedule a follow-up call in 7 days

• Notify shipping to dispatch the product

You can also push order data directly to third-party fulfilment systems like Dropbox, making it ideal for ecommerce or service-based businesses with deliverables.

5. Integrated Membership Functionality

If you run a membership site, Office Autopilot offers seamless integration with WordPress. Combine this with tags and rules, and you’ve got a powerful client portal or members-only resource centre.

What About the Price?

Yes, Mailchimp is cheaper up front, as little as $20–$50/month. But by the time you add CRM software, email segmentation tools, and process automation, the total monthly cost climbs quickly.

Office Autopilot starts at $297/month, but the time saved, revenue recovered, and system power far outweigh the investment. In our case, the efficiency gains paid for themselves within weeks.

Final Verdict

If you’re just starting out or only sending newsletters, Mailchimp might do the job. But if you want an integrated, scalable, automated CRM and marketing platform, Office Autopilot (Ontraport) is the smarter long-term solution.

We made the switch and haven’t looked back.

Meeting with Gavin Bateman

Book Now

Disclaimer:

The information provided in this article is general in nature and does not constitute personal financial, legal or tax advice. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of this content at the time of publication, tax laws and regulations may change, and individual circumstances vary. Dolman Bateman accepts no responsibility or liability for any loss or damage incurred as a result of acting on or relying upon any of the information contained herein. You should seek professional advice tailored to your specific situation before making any financial or tax decision.